I watched A Gentleman’s Agreement today, which, if you have not seen it yet, you should. It was quite revolutionary for the time it was made, it took on anti-Semitism at a time when anti-Semitism was rampant, politely accepted and pretty much just the way things were. The movie was, I think, ahead of its time. Gregory Peck is amazing, well he’s Atticus Finch/Superman/and a big damn hero all rolled up in one, isn’t he? He’s no less epic in this film than he was in Mockingbird. He’s amazing. The film itself is, to me, very brave.
There’s this very memorable speech by Ann Revere towards the end of the film:
“You know something, Phil? I suddenly want to live to be very old. Very. I want to be around to see what happens. The world is stirring in very strange ways. Maybe this is the century for it. Maybe that’s why it’s so troubled. Other centuries had their driving forces. What will ours have been when men look back? Maybe it won’t be the American century after all… or the Russian century or the atomic century. Wouldn’t it be wonderful… if it turned out to be everybody’s century… when people all over the world – free people – found a way to live together? I’d like to be around to see some of that… even the beginning. I may stick around for quite a while.”
Well, I don’t think it was everyone’s century, but I think we got a good start on some of that stuff. I think we’re getting there.
I found the movie, in light of some of the stuff going on right now here in CA, to be really relevant.
I grew up Jewish in a small rural town. We were not, like, a visible community. I was the only Jewish kid in my school. The thing about Jewishness (esp. if you are Ashkenazi, which I am, it is possibly harder if you look Semitic and not European, I would guess), people don’t immediately see you as being Jewish unless you tell them, or your name is Jewish sounding or it comes up. I know my experience is really very different from that of a person of color in that I can walk into a room and choose to identify myself as such, or not. Jewish people have plenty of experience of being in the closet – particularly in early to mid part of the last century. They had to be. They couldn’t get jobs or into many clubs, organizations or certain colleges or buy homes in some areas if they were “out”. If your name was Greenblatt in the 1930’s and 40’s, odds are you got a lot of rejection letters and I bet it was hard to find an apartment in a Gentile neighborhood. My grandmother’s family changed their name from a Jewish sounding name to a very plain American sounding one – they became the Myles family rather than Moserowitz. It made life easier.
I sometimes feel a little marginalized when it comes to discussing prejudice because I’m not an obvious person of color. However, being called things like “Christkiller, Kike, Yid” or worse, and getting pushed and shoved around on a regular basis because of my religion as I grew up sucked and hey, guess what, it was because of prejudice. Yet, oddly there was still a kind of blanket acceptance in the larger context because I looked just like them. As long as the Jewish thing could be ignored it was ok – and it was a lot of the time. I find it hard to claim my experience when I’m having discussions about this. Grey area. Not hard enough? Not sure. Different, at least.
I’m experiencing similar feelings around the current situation in CA.
Again, with the choice. I can choose so many things. I can choose to out myself about things or keep them to myself. I can choose to marry or not. I get a choice in the matter and the problem is that there’s this whole segment of the population that gets NO choice. And being refused that choice to marry or not marry, to identify or not identify, to be SAFE or not safe – NOT FAIR – it’s broken.
I’m trying to figure out what it means to live with the fact that I can choose how I am perceived and others can’t choose that. I am trying to figure out how to effectively help in the larger picture.
Harvey Milk said, “Burst down those closet doors once and for all, and stand up and start to fight.”
So let me step out of the closet entirely. The reason I can choose to marry, or not, is that I’ve dated women and I’ve dated men and am happy either way. I am and have always defined myself as queer. I have not been out about this in this space, though most of my friends and family are aware. Most, not all. Mostly because I felt like it was nobody’s #@$! business, but yes, partially because I was really afraid of some of the potential repercussions and that, friends, makes me a big damn coward.
So here’s the thing. As someone who could best be described as bisexual or flexible, I don’t really, at all, feel like a real part of the GLBT “Community” – I know there’s a letter in there that is supposed to include me but it hasn’t ever felt inclusive of what I am. It never has. “Ally” is a better descriptive of my own relationship with the community. I also feel way isolated/marginalized in the straight community because see, I know that I’m really not and that I’m not telling so people are making decisions about me based on false pretenses. I am also oriented towards polyamory and committedly so, though have not always been out on that front either. That is not something that either community is entirely comfortable with. I exist in this weird, narrow marginal space that’s hard to define as either/or and I have always had the choice to out myself or not, based on whether it felt safe to do so. I’m tired of worrying about being safe.
I am waiting for the time when we stop being so divisive with each other. I want that to happen because we are all enjoying equal rights and protections and perceptions of each other. I want it to be everybody’s century. So much. EVERYBODY’S CENTURY. I want to stick around and see that. I know it’s coming. I just want it now and I want it to be a lot less confusing than it is for everyone. We need to sort this stuff out.
Oh and one last word on “tolerance”. We need to throw the idea of “tolerance” in the garbage where it belongs. You “tolerate” the flu, annoying atonal jazz music, a bad smell, the dude in the line in front of you paying with pennies when you’re in a hurry, traffic on the 405 and scooping the catbox. You “tolerate” people like that lunatic who protests at funerals with the nasty signs, people who vote against marriage equality and churches based outside my state that spend hundreds of thousands of dollars to manipulate our election though frankly you should not have to because they are intolerable. To “tolerate” the GLBT community, Jews, people of color, Muslims or any other minority is insulting to those people because you are equating them with things that are not good.
How about the day when rather than tolerance, we simply expect blanket acceptance for everyone on the grounds that we’re all just folks here, for whatever value of folks that may be?